Grade 12 · Art

Compare and contrast the principles of design, including emphasis, repetition/pattern, movement/rhythm, contrast/variety, balance, proportion, and unity, in personal artwork

Quarter 1 · Week 9 · TEKS

Standards Alignment

  • TEKS.117.305.01C primary
    compare and contrast the principles of design, including emphasis, repetition/pattern, movement/rhythm, contrast/variety, balance, proportion, and unity, in personal artwork; and
  • TEKS.117.305.01D primary
    discriminate between art media and processes to express complex visual relationships such as content, meaning, message, and metaphor using extensive art vocabulary.

Lesson Overview

This Grade 12 art lesson guides students to compare and contrast the principles of design — emphasis, repetition/pattern, movement/rhythm, contrast/variety, balance, proportion, and unity — within their own artwork. Students will observe examples, create original pieces applying these principles, and reflect on their artistic decisions using extensive art vocabulary. The lesson aligns with TEKS standards and develops students' visual literacy, critical thinking, and expressive skills.

Learning Objectives

  • Identify and describe the principles of design in personal artwork, including emphasis, repetition/pattern, movement/rhythm, contrast/variety, balance, proportion, and unity.
  • Compare and contrast how these principles are used in different personal artworks.
  • Use appropriate art vocabulary to explain complex visual relationships such as content, meaning, message, and metaphor in artwork.
  • Create original artwork that demonstrates intentional use of multiple principles of design.
  • Reflect on and justify artistic choices related to design principles using evaluative criteria.

Success Criteria

  • Students can accurately identify and explain the principles of design in their own and peers' artwork.
  • Students can compare and contrast the use of design principles across different artworks.
  • Students use extensive art vocabulary to discuss visual relationships and artistic intent.
  • Students produce original artwork that intentionally applies at least three principles of design.
  • Students articulate reasons for their artistic decisions referencing design principles and visual effects.

Prerequisite Knowledge

Students should be familiar with basic art elements (line, shape, color, texture, space) and have prior experience creating artwork using various media. They should understand foundational art vocabulary and have practiced observing and describing artworks.

Key Vocabulary

  • Principles of Design
  • Emphasis
  • Repetition
  • Pattern
  • Movement
  • Rhythm
  • Contrast
  • Variety
  • Balance
  • Proportion
  • Unity
  • Visual Literacy
  • Art Vocabulary
  • Content
  • Meaning
  • Message
  • Metaphor

Materials and Resources

  • Examples of artworks illustrating various principles of design (printed or digital)
  • Drawing or painting supplies (paper, pencils, paints, brushes, etc.)
  • Sketchbooks or journals for reflection
  • Art vocabulary reference handouts or posters

Teacher Preparation

  • Select diverse artworks that clearly demonstrate different principles of design for observation and discussion.
  • Prepare a vocabulary list and definitions for principles of design and related art terms.
  • Plan a demonstration showing how to analyze and compare design principles in artwork.
  • Set up materials for students to create original artwork applying design principles.
  • Prepare reflection prompts to guide student discussion and self-assessment.

Detailed Lesson Notes

Principles of Design Overview

The principles of design are guidelines artists use to organize the elements of art within a composition. They include emphasis (focal point), repetition/pattern (repeated elements), movement/rhythm (visual flow), contrast/variety (differences that create interest), balance (distribution of visual weight), proportion (size relationships), and unity (harmony of all parts). Understanding these helps artists create visually compelling and meaningful works.

Emphasis and Focal Points

Emphasis directs the viewer’s attention to the most important part of the artwork, often called the focal point. Artists achieve emphasis through contrast, placement, color, size, or detail. For example, a bright red object in a muted background creates emphasis. Students should observe how emphasis guides the eye and creates meaning in artworks.

Repetition, Pattern, Movement, and Rhythm

Repetition involves using the same or similar elements multiple times to create pattern or rhythm. Pattern is a repeated decorative design, while rhythm creates a sense of movement or flow. For instance, repeating shapes or colors can lead the viewer’s eye across the artwork, producing a dynamic effect. Students should compare how repetition differs from rhythm and how both contribute to visual interest.

Contrast and Variety

Contrast is the difference between elements, such as light vs. dark or rough vs. smooth, which adds variety and excitement. Variety prevents monotony by including diverse elements or techniques. Students should analyze how contrast and variety affect mood and focus in artworks and how artists balance these to maintain unity.

Balance and Proportion

Balance refers to the distribution of visual weight in a composition, which can be symmetrical, asymmetrical, or radial. Proportion is the size relationship between parts of the artwork. Correct proportion helps create realism or intentional distortion for effect. Students should observe different types of balance and how proportion influences the overall harmony.

Unity and Harmony

Unity is the sense that all parts of the artwork belong together, creating a cohesive whole. Artists achieve unity by consistent use of color, style, or theme. Harmony supports unity by blending elements smoothly. Students should reflect on how unity affects the viewer’s experience and how it can be maintained while using contrast and variety.

Comparing and Contrasting Principles in Personal Artwork

Students will examine their own artwork and that of peers to identify which principles are most prominent and how they are applied differently. For example, one artwork might emphasize strong contrast and asymmetrical balance, while another uses repetition and rhythm to create movement. Comparing these helps deepen understanding of design choices and their effects.

Using Art Vocabulary to Express Complex Visual Relationships

Students will practice using precise art vocabulary to describe how principles of design communicate content, meaning, message, or metaphor in artwork. For example, explaining how emphasis creates a focal point that conveys importance, or how rhythm suggests movement or emotion. This skill supports critical thinking and artistic expression.

Creating Original Artwork Applying Principles of Design

Students will plan and create an original artwork that intentionally applies multiple principles of design. They should consider how to use emphasis, balance, and unity, for example, to convey a personal message or theme. This process encourages experimentation and reflection on artistic decisions.

Reflecting and Justifying Artistic Choices

After creating artwork, students will share their work and explain their use of design principles, discussing how these choices affect meaning and viewer experience. They will use evaluative criteria to justify decisions, such as why they chose a particular balance or contrast. This reflection develops metacognitive skills and art critique ability.

Worked Examples

Worked Example 1

Scenario

Look at two student artworks: Artwork A uses a large bright red shape in the center with muted background colors, and Artwork B uses repeated blue shapes flowing diagonally across the page. Compare and contrast the use of emphasis and movement in these artworks.

Explanation

Artwork A uses emphasis by placing a bright red shape centrally, drawing the viewer’s eye immediately to that focal point. The muted background supports this emphasis by not competing for attention. Artwork B uses repetition of blue shapes arranged diagonally to create movement, guiding the viewer’s eye along the flow of shapes. While Artwork A focuses on emphasis to create a focal point, Artwork B emphasizes movement through rhythm and pattern. Both use principles of design to control visual experience but achieve different effects.

Answer Guide

Artwork A demonstrates emphasis by using a bright, central shape to create a focal point, while Artwork B uses repetition and pattern to create movement and rhythm across the page. Artwork A’s design draws attention to one spot, whereas Artwork B’s design leads the eye through the composition.

Engage

Teacher Activity

Introduce the lesson by showing several diverse artworks that clearly demonstrate different principles of design. Ask students to observe and discuss what they notice about how the artworks are organized visually.

Student Activity

Observe the displayed artworks and share initial thoughts about what draws their attention or what patterns and movements they see.

Explanation

This phase activates prior knowledge and curiosity about design principles by engaging students in visual analysis and discussion.

Examples

  • Students identify focal points or areas of emphasis.
  • Students notice repeated elements forming patterns or rhythm.
  • Students describe movement or flow of the eye.
  • Students recognize contrasts in color, texture, or shape.
  • Students comment on balance and proportion.
  • Students sense unity or harmony in the composition.

Explore

Teacher Activity

Guide students to analyze their own and peers' artworks to identify and compare the principles of design used. Provide vocabulary support and examples.

Student Activity

Examine artworks and use art vocabulary to describe the principles of design present. Compare how different artworks use these principles similarly or differently.

Explanation

This phase deepens understanding by applying vocabulary and critical thinking to real examples, fostering analytical skills.

Examples

  • Students accurately identify multiple principles of design.
  • Students articulate differences and similarities in design use.
  • Students use appropriate vocabulary to explain visual effects.
  • Students begin to form evaluative opinions based on design principles.

Explain

Teacher Activity

Explicitly teach definitions and examples of each principle of design. Model how to compare and contrast these principles in artworks using clear art vocabulary.

Student Activity

Listen and take notes on definitions and examples. Practice articulating comparisons between principles in sample artworks.

Explanation

This phase provides direct instruction to clarify concepts and vocabulary, supporting student mastery.

Examples

  • Students demonstrate understanding of each principle.
  • Students correctly use vocabulary in explanations.
  • Students can distinguish between similar principles like contrast and variety.

Elaborate

Teacher Activity

Facilitate students creating original artwork that intentionally applies multiple principles of design. Encourage planning and reflection on artistic choices.

Student Activity

Plan and create an artwork using at least three principles of design. Reflect on how these principles help express content or meaning.

Explanation

This phase allows students to apply knowledge creatively and thoughtfully, reinforcing learning through practice.

Examples

  • Students produce artworks showing intentional design choices.
  • Students articulate reasons for their use of principles.
  • Students experiment with different media and techniques.

Evaluate

Teacher Activity

Lead a critique session where students share their artwork and explain their use of design principles. Provide feedback and guide reflection using evaluative criteria.

Student Activity

Present artwork, describe design principles used, and respond to peer and teacher feedback.

Explanation

This phase develops critical thinking and communication skills by reflecting on artistic decisions and receiving constructive critique.

Examples

  • Students clearly explain their artistic choices.
  • Students engage respectfully in critique.
  • Students reflect on strengths and areas for growth.
  • Students connect design principles to visual impact and meaning.

Classroom Activity

Examine artworks and use art vocabulary to describe the principles of design present. Compare how different artworks use these principles similarly or differently.

Guided Practice

Guided Practice 1

Prompt

Name three principles of design and give a simple example of each from everyday objects or images.

Teacher Answer Guide

Examples include: Emphasis - a stop sign’s red color draws attention; Repetition - stripes on a shirt; Balance - a symmetrical face.

Guided Practice 2

Prompt

Look at your own artwork and identify two principles of design you used. Describe how you applied them.

Teacher Answer Guide

Answers will vary; for example, a student might say they used balance by arranging shapes evenly and emphasis by making one color brighter to draw attention.

Guided Practice 3

Prompt

Compare two artworks you have created or observed. How does each use contrast and variety differently?

Teacher Answer Guide

One artwork might use strong color contrasts to create excitement, while another uses subtle texture contrasts for interest. Variety might be shown by different shapes in one artwork and different colors in another.

Guided Practice 4

Prompt

Analyze how movement and rhythm are created in a chosen artwork. What elements contribute to this effect?

Teacher Answer Guide

Movement and rhythm can be created by repeated lines or shapes arranged in a flowing pattern. Elements like diagonal lines, repeated colors, or shapes spaced evenly contribute to visual movement.

Guided Practice 5

Prompt

Create a plan for an original artwork that uses at least four principles of design to express a personal message. Explain your choices.

Teacher Answer Guide

A student might plan to use emphasis by highlighting a central figure, balance by arranging elements symmetrically, contrast by using light and dark colors, and unity by repeating shapes and colors to tie the composition together. The choices support the message by focusing attention and creating harmony.

Independent Practice

  1. Foundational: Name three principles of design and give a simple example of each from everyday objects or images.
  2. Developing: Look at your own artwork and identify two principles of design you used. Describe how you applied them.
  3. Application: Compare two artworks you have created or observed. How does each use contrast and variety differently?
  4. Analysis: Analyze how movement and rhythm are created in a chosen artwork. What elements contribute to this effect?
  5. Challenge: Create a plan for an original artwork that uses at least four principles of design to express a personal message. Explain your choices.

Independent Practice Teacher Answer Key

  1. 1. Examples include: Emphasis - a stop sign’s red color draws attention; Repetition - stripes on a shirt; Balance - a symmetrical face.
  2. 2. Answers will vary; for example, a student might say they used balance by arranging shapes evenly and emphasis by making one color brighter to draw attention.
  3. 3. One artwork might use strong color contrasts to create excitement, while another uses subtle texture contrasts for interest. Variety might be shown by different shapes in one artwork and different colors in another.
  4. 4. Movement and rhythm can be created by repeated lines or shapes arranged in a flowing pattern. Elements like diagonal lines, repeated colors, or shapes spaced evenly contribute to visual movement.
  5. 5. A student might plan to use emphasis by highlighting a central figure, balance by arranging elements symmetrically, contrast by using light and dark colors, and unity by repeating shapes and colors to tie the composition together. The choices support the message by focusing attention and creating harmony.

Guiding Questions

  • What are the main principles of design used in this artwork?
  • How do different artworks use emphasis or balance differently?
  • Why might an artist choose to use repetition or contrast?
  • How do design principles affect the meaning or message of an artwork?
  • How can you use these principles to improve your own artwork?

Common Misconceptions

  • Emphasis means making everything bright or colorful, but it actually means creating a focal point that stands out from other elements.
  • Repetition and pattern are the same as rhythm; rhythm involves movement and flow, not just repeated elements.
  • Balance always means symmetry; balance can also be asymmetrical or radial.
  • Unity means everything must look the same; unity is about harmony and coherence, not uniformity.
  • Contrast is only about color differences; it can also involve texture, shape, size, and value differences.

Differentiation

Support and Intervention

Provide vocabulary cards with definitions and examples for reference. Use guided questions to help students identify principles in artworks. Allow use of sketchbooks to plan artwork before creating final piece.

English-Language Learner Support

Use visual aids and labeled diagrams to explain principles of design. Pair ELL students with peers for discussion and vocabulary practice. Provide sentence starters for describing artworks and artistic choices.

Advanced and Extension

Challenge students to analyze complex artworks from museums or galleries using detailed art vocabulary. Encourage exploration of metaphor and meaning through design principles in their artwork. Have students lead critique sessions and develop evaluative criteria for artwork.

Assessment

  • Students identify principles of design in sample artworks during class discussion.
  • Students explain their use of design principles in their own artwork.
  • Students participate in critique sessions using art vocabulary.
  • List three principles of design and explain how one was used in your artwork.
  • Describe one way your artwork uses balance or proportion.
  • Explain how you created emphasis or movement in your artwork.
  • Write an essay comparing and contrasting the principles of design in two artworks.
  • Create a portfolio of original artworks demonstrating different principles of design with written reflections.
  • Present a critique analyzing the use of design principles in a famous artwork.

Answer Guide

  • Name three principles of design and give a simple example of each from everyday objects or images.
    Answer: Examples include: Emphasis - a stop sign’s red color draws attention; Repetition - stripes on a shirt; Balance - a symmetrical face.
  • Look at your own artwork and identify two principles of design you used. Describe how you applied them.
    Answer: Answers will vary; for example, a student might say they used balance by arranging shapes evenly and emphasis by making one color brighter to draw attention.
  • Compare two artworks you have created or observed. How does each use contrast and variety differently?
    Answer: One artwork might use strong color contrasts to create excitement, while another uses subtle texture contrasts for interest. Variety might be shown by different shapes in one artwork and different colors in another.
  • Analyze how movement and rhythm are created in a chosen artwork. What elements contribute to this effect?
    Answer: Movement and rhythm can be created by repeated lines or shapes arranged in a flowing pattern. Elements like diagonal lines, repeated colors, or shapes spaced evenly contribute to visual movement.
  • Create a plan for an original artwork that uses at least four principles of design to express a personal message. Explain your choices.
    Answer: A student might plan to use emphasis by highlighting a central figure, balance by arranging elements symmetrically, contrast by using light and dark colors, and unity by repeating shapes and colors to tie the composition together. The choices support the message by focusing attention and creating harmony.

Real-Life Application

Encourage students to observe and photograph examples of design principles in their home or community environment. They can bring photos or sketches to class and discuss how these principles appear in everyday life.

Homework or Home Connection

  • Encourage students to observe and photograph examples of design principles in their home or community environment. They can bring photos or sketches to class and discuss how these principles appear in everyday life.

Lesson Summary

In this lesson, students learn to identify, compare, and contrast the principles of design in personal and peer artworks. They develop vocabulary and critical thinking skills to describe how these principles create meaning and visual interest. Through creating original artwork and reflecting on artistic choices, students deepen their understanding of how emphasis, repetition, movement, contrast, balance, proportion, and unity work together to communicate ideas visually.

Teacher Notes

Use the exact standards alignment and retrieved-source provenance stored with this enrichment.

Related Lessons